In 1935, the death of a coal miner in Pound, Virginia, led to the arrest of his 21-year-old daughter, schoolteacher Edith Maxwell. Edith claimed she acted in self-defense, but conflicting accounts of what happened inside the family home raised troubling questions.
Her murder trials attracted national attention and drew the nation into a debate over justice.
This episode of Southern Mysteries examines the evidence, the conflicting testimony and the questions surrounding one of Virginia’s most controversial murder cases.
💌 Join the Community on Patreon
Additionally, you can hear the Southern Mysteries archive of 60+ episodes and the Patron podcast Audacious: Tales of American Crime.
You can immediately access exclusive content now at patreon.com/southernmysteries.

Episode Sources
- Hatfield, Sharon. Never Seen the Moon: The Trials of Edith Maxwell. University of Illinois Press, 2005.
- Maxwell v. Commonwealth, 167 Va. 490, 187 S.E. 506. Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia, September 11, 1936.
- Maxwell v. Commonwealth. Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia, November 1937. Decision affirming Edith Maxwell’s second-degree murder conviction.
- Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph. Interview series with Edith Maxwell, December 15–31, 1935.
- Washington Herald. December 1, 1935. Interview and reporting concerning Earl Maxwell and the Maxwell family.
- Winchester Evening Star. December 15, 1936. Coverage of Mary Katherine Maxwell’s testimony during Edith’s second trial.
- La Grande Evening Observer. December 17, 1936. Coverage of Edith Maxwell’s second trial and conviction.
- Pyle, Ernie. Washington Daily News. December 1935. Reporting from Pound, Virginia, concerning the Edith Maxwell case.
- Thurber, James. “Crime in the Cumberlands.” The New Yorker, February 1936.
- Library of Virginia. Virginia Women in History: Edith Maxwell. Historical records, prison documentation and materials concerning Edith Maxwell’s case.
- McNulty, Charles S. Letter to Virginia Gov. James H. Price, May 5, 1938. Library of Virginia, executive correspondence.
- Kates, Elizabeth M. Letter to Virginia Gov. James H. Price, October 25, 1941. Library of Virginia, executive correspondence.
- Price, James H. Correspondence concerning the pardon of Edith Maxwell, December 19, 1941. Library of Virginia.
- Library of Congress. National Woman’s Party records and historical materials concerning the campaign for Edith Maxwell’s appeal.
Episode Music
Out of the Mines, courtesy of Ross Gentry, Asheville, North Carolina.
