Episode 2o1 | Mountain Murder: The Edith Maxwell Story

In 1935, the death of a coal miner in Pound, Virginia, led to the arrest of his 21-year-old daughter, schoolteacher Edith Maxwell. Edith claimed she acted in self-defense, but conflicting accounts of what happened inside the family home raised troubling questions.

Her murder trials attracted national attention and drew the nation into a debate over justice.

This episode of Southern Mysteries examines the evidence, the conflicting testimony and the questions surrounding one of Virginia’s most controversial murder cases.

💌 Join the Community on Patreon

Additionally, you can hear the Southern Mysteries archive of 60+ episodes and the Patron podcast Audacious: Tales of American Crime.

You can immediately access exclusive content now at patreon.com/southernmysteries.

Episode Sources

  • Hatfield, Sharon. Never Seen the Moon: The Trials of Edith Maxwell. University of Illinois Press, 2005.
  • Maxwell v. Commonwealth, 167 Va. 490, 187 S.E. 506. Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia, September 11, 1936.
  • Maxwell v. Commonwealth. Supreme Court of Appeals of Virginia, November 1937. Decision affirming Edith Maxwell’s second-degree murder conviction.
  • Pittsburgh Sun-Telegraph. Interview series with Edith Maxwell, December 15–31, 1935.
  • Washington Herald. December 1, 1935. Interview and reporting concerning Earl Maxwell and the Maxwell family.
  • Winchester Evening Star. December 15, 1936. Coverage of Mary Katherine Maxwell’s testimony during Edith’s second trial.
  • La Grande Evening Observer. December 17, 1936. Coverage of Edith Maxwell’s second trial and conviction.
  • Pyle, Ernie. Washington Daily News. December 1935. Reporting from Pound, Virginia, concerning the Edith Maxwell case.
  • Thurber, James. “Crime in the Cumberlands.” The New Yorker, February 1936.
  • Library of Virginia. Virginia Women in History: Edith Maxwell. Historical records, prison documentation and materials concerning Edith Maxwell’s case.
  • McNulty, Charles S. Letter to Virginia Gov. James H. Price, May 5, 1938. Library of Virginia, executive correspondence.
  • Kates, Elizabeth M. Letter to Virginia Gov. James H. Price, October 25, 1941. Library of Virginia, executive correspondence.
  • Price, James H. Correspondence concerning the pardon of Edith Maxwell, December 19, 1941. Library of Virginia.
  • Library of Congress. National Woman’s Party records and historical materials concerning the campaign for Edith Maxwell’s appeal.

Episode Music

Out of the Mines, courtesy of Ross Gentry, Asheville, North Carolina.

Scroll to Top